The Final of Us Half II Is a Revolutionary Video Sport—and an Unbelievably Grim One

In Naughty Canine’s 2013 online game The Final of Us, a horrible illness swept the world, the American authorities started to kill its personal residents and survivors turned to tribalism. Seven years later, that after distant dystopia doesn’t really feel so farfetched, and the sport’s long-awaited sequel, The Final of Us Half II (out June 19), could show a harder promote for even die-hard players at this significantly making an attempt second.

The primary sport was a shocking accomplishment that pushed the bounds of the format. Gamers witnessed the apocalypse primarily via the eyes of Joel (Troy Baker), who escorted a 14-year-old named Ellie (Ashley Johnson), the one recognized individual resistant to zombie bites, from Boston to a hospital in Seattle the place medical doctors had been making an attempt to develop a vaccine. Joel grew keen on Ellie throughout the journey. At the same time as they dodged the undead and, scarier nonetheless, the dwelling, their banter buoyed the darkish sport: They mentioned Ellie’s love of comedian books and corny knock-knock jokes as they explored the bombed-out stays of faculties and condominium complexes. With out Joel and Ellie’s touching relationship, The Final of Us would have been little greater than a ripoff of The Street.

Joel and Ellie’s bond proves important within the remaining chapter of the unique sport, hailed by many critics as an ideal ending, when Joel realizes that Ellie will die within the operation essential to create a vaccine and decides to stage an escape. After I first performed, I attempted to search out methods to avoid wasting an unconscious Ellie with out brutally murdering dozens of medical doctors and nurses. However ultimately, I spotted that killing unarmed medical staff was the one strategy to beat the sport. It’s a horrifying and complex second for the participant, and it’s unclear how the forthcoming HBO TV adaptation, a collaboration between the sport’s director and the creator of HBO’s equally harrowing Chernobyl, will be capable of seize that very same feeling for a passive viewer.

The genius of the sport was that the story progressively constructed towards one remaining second that compelled the participant to reckon with whether or not the nominal hero of the story was, in actual fact, a villain. Within the sequel, nonetheless, the participant is requested to commit ethically doubtful acts not simply as soon as, however on a minute-to-minute foundation, diminishing the facility of what’s certain to be a controversial finale.

This time, we play primarily as Ellie, now 19 years previous and on a mission that I received’t spoil in a war-torn Seattle. Town has turn into a battleground the place the militant Washington Liberation Entrance faces off in opposition to a cult that goes by the identify the Saraphites. It’s an engrossing world: The graphics are stunning, the motion-capture faces gorgeously rendered. The mechanics of the unique Final of Us had been at all times a bit of clunky and cumbersome, however transferring via the world of The Final of Us Half II is seamless. Weapons and instruments are nonetheless scarce, and the sport nonetheless encourages stealth over confrontation. Nonetheless, when Ellie does come to blows with an enemy, the preventing is fluid but difficult.

And struggle, she does. The only-minded Ellie will shoot, bludgeon or shank anybody who will get in her means, no matter political ideology. Enemies who, in video games like Grand Theft Auto or Naughty Canine’s personal Uncharted, would stay anonymous and faceless get sympathetic backstories right here. After you kill them, considered one of their pals may name out their identify in anguish, compounding your guilt. The Washington Liberation Entrance makes use of canine to hunt Ellie down, and whereas often the participant can circumvent these animals, too usually it’s a must to kill them too. (See additionally: Chernobyl.) The story is so dreary and cynical that some of Naughty Dog’s own developers protested the route the sport was taking, in line with Naughty Canine’s head Neil Druckmann.

But when Naughty Canine’s intent was to shock, leaning so closely on the violence has the alternative impact: 30 hours into the sport, it’s straightforward to develop numb to acts of cruelty. That awe-inducing surroundings and cautious character-building is misplaced in macabre motion. And whereas the violence of the primary sport served a compelling ethical story, the over-the-top bloodshed of Half II is all in service of a quite clichéd and tiresome lesson concerning the countless cycle of revenge. The banter that elevated the primary sport above mere dystopian fantasy is gone too, as Ellie usually navigates this ultra-violent world on her personal. It makes for a lonely, miserable expertise at a second when many people are already feeling lonely and depressed.

Final of Us Half II

Naughty Canine

Nonetheless, it’s a uncommon AAA online game that can take any form of danger — and Naughty Canine takes a variety of dangers. For some, it will likely be price enduring dozens of hours of harrowing gameplay to expertise a blockbuster sport making an attempt to interrupt the mildew, whether or not or not most gamers are glad with the ending. Antiheroes aren’t new to video video games, however Naughty Canine pushes the idea to its edge, shifting the participant’s perspective in compelling, if typically irritating, scenes.

And it’s no small factor that Naughty Canine determined to primarily inform this story not with the standard white, straight, male antihero, however a homosexual lady. Ellie’s bisexual girlfriend Dina and a trans character (whose identification I’m not permitted to spoil) additionally play main roles. The ladies within the sport don’t have the buxom our bodies nonetheless well-liked amongst many sport builders, however practical and diversified builds. This form of range continues to be radical for a mainstream online game, although the core forged of characters stays primarily white, and the sport avoids any acknowledgment of the obtrusive racial divide on this nation, which might not merely dissipate in a post-apocalyptic world.

Nonetheless, explorations of sexism, homophobia and transphobia within the sport open up new avenues which have largely been lacking from mainstream video video games. A concerted effort by the #gamergate motion has pushed again in opposition to any online game firm that dares to increase its perspective in these methods. At the same time as notable female-led video video games have impressed followers and critics (together with current triumphs like Horizon Zero Daybreak and Management), little progress has been made. Final yr, the web site Feminist Frequency found that the variety of video video games with feminine protagonists on the E3 Expo (the premiere online game expo) was decrease in 2019 than it was in 2015 when the #gamergate motion caught hearth.

Unsurprisingly, The Final of Us II has garnered its fair proportion of trolls even earlier than its launch. After a trailer that featured a kiss between Ellie and Dina dropped in 2018, outrage started to brew amongst a small however loud contingent of followers on-line. A number of weeks earlier than Naughty Canine was set to launch the sport, footage and particulars of the plot leaked. As plot twists went viral, Naughty Canine’s social media channels and staff’ private accounts had been flooded with sexist, homophobic and transphobic slurs, forcing the corporate to disable commenting.

Some poisonous YouTubers and Reddit posters have advocated for boycotting the sport for a bunch of suspect causes. Some are sad that they must play as a queer 19-year-old woman quite than a grizzled middle-aged man they know and love — a criticism that mirrors followers’ outrage over the loss of life of Luke Skywalker and the ascendence of his protégé Rey within the Star Wars collection. Others have balked at what they label as Naughty Canine’s progressive political agenda, which they declare was influenced by feminists they name SJWs (social justice warriors). These arguments are often wrapped up in complaints about Naughty Canine’s daring plotting selections, and it’s arduous to untangle the true gripes about story from political agenda.

These trolls are following a well-worn playbook: They bully anybody related to an previous property, as soon as dominated by straight white males, that has since advanced. The disturbing factor is, they usually win: After indignant Ghostbusters followers protested the all-female reboot by lobbing racist and sexist slurs at comic Leslie Jones, the studio greenlit a brand new Ghostbusters sequel that ignores the existence of the movie starring Jones. After trolls harassed Star Wars actress Kelly Marie Tran to the purpose the place she left social media, Tran received all however written out of the final installment of Star Wars.

Not like the film studios which have capitulated to fan demands, Naughty Canine, to its credit score, has refused to budge on its dedication to all features of The Final of Us Half II. On the sport’s press tour, Druckmann has repeatedly stated that diversifying the story’s characters has allowed them to create a extra fascinating narrative — although he’s additionally warned followers that this specific story is not going to be “consolation meals.” If those that embrace it are finally let down by its unrelenting bleakness, they’ll no less than take coronary heart within the chance that it’s paved the best way for one thing simply as groundbreaking — and a bit of extra optimistic — to comply with in its footsteps.

Get The Transient. Signal as much as obtain the highest tales you must know proper now.


To your safety, we have despatched a affirmation e-mail to the tackle you entered. Click on the hyperlink to substantiate your subscription and start receiving our newsletters. If you aren’t getting the affirmation inside 10 minutes, please test your spam folder.

Write to Eliana Dockterman at

Read More


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here